Don’t Forget to Smile!

Notes on reviews of Vitaly Mansky’s Under the Sun

Under the Sun

In mid-May, the Czech-German-Russian co-production documentary entitled Under the Sun won the Golden Kingfisher Award for the best documentary film at the Finále Plzeň film festival. This is not the first (most probably also not the last) award the film has garnered. Vitaly Mansky’s documentary work depicting the life of a seemingly ordinary North Korean family is also the winner of the award at the 19th Jihlava IDFF’s Between the Seas section, the Best Director award at Tallinn’s Black Nights festival, the Best Documentary Award at Trieste festival – and its winning streak is far from over.

Mansky and his director of photography defied Korean propaganda by secretly preserving all of the captured video recordings. Every day, they were asked to hand in the recordings for approval to Korean officials, who immediately deleted unacceptable footage and returned the card containing only approved images. However, none of them realised that modern technologies are able to save the recorded footage on two memory cards simultaneously. Mansky thus managed to show a look behind the scenes of the making of his documentary in Communist North Korea following a script, praised even by the venerated leader Kim Jong Il.

International reviewers have suggested that the film could be easily renamed to “Don’t Forget to Smile!“ ( Mansky leaves the camera running to capture Korean “filmmakers” preparing a perfect film set – instructing children to smile more, ordering dairy workers to clap hands to celebrate their success and tell little Zin-Mi, the main protagonist, not to be afraid and act naturally as if she were at home. The central topic of the majority of both Czech and foreign reviews is the clash of the artificial “happy” and colourful reality and that as could be expected in the streets of North Korea – empty streets, sunless sky, greyness and silence.

A review published in September 2015 in Screen notes that: “This film is a high-quality package about a newsworthy but little-seen subject: a life beyond the festival circuit seems certain.” It praises Mansky for his ability to – in spite of the strict control (and perhaps thanks to its rigidity) – to show the everyday and ordinary aspects of the life “in the best country in the world”. Mansky himself stated he had been disappointed to have failed to find ordinary people living ordinary lives in Korea and so he decided to make a film about fake Korean reality. This false reality can be best represented by the final scene showing an eight-year-old girl forced to tears by the omnipresent drill, cameras, her parents and other governmental officials; when she is asked to recall some funny or nice moments, she starts reciting a poem in praise of the Supreme leader.

However, many reviewers have been misled into putting Mansky’s work on an uncritical pedestal, without giving it a more thorough thought. Indeed, the director spent a year in North Korea risking his life thus undoubtedly manifesting great courage and investing a remarkable amount of energy in the film’s production. Nevertheless, this fact overshadows Mansky’s brilliant ability to intensify the film’s atmosphere through long takes that allow the viewer to get more absorbed in the images making the presented topic more tangible and immediate.

Some critics have even made a daring claim that they can see the numerous festival awards transforming into a great international distribution and broadcasting (TV) success (The Guardian, The Hollywood Reporter, Cineuropa). Once these predictions are fulfilled, some Korean governmental officials will certainly be summoned to give a detailed explanation to their Supreme leader.

more articles from a section:  Sport

1.21Pandemic as an opportunityJi.hlava's Emerging Producers discuss the opportunity that can emerge from crisisSteve Rickinson
1+2.19How to Teach Documentary FilmmakingThis year’s Ji.hlava IDFF offered a panel discussion on how documentary filmmaking is taught in Visegrad countries. Methods used to teach documentary filmmaking in different V4 countries were discussed by lecturers from selected schools. Vít Janeček introduced documentary courses at Prague’s FAMU, Attila Kékesi represented Hungarian University of Theatre and Film Arts in Budapest, Viera Čákanyová talked about study programmes at Slovak Academy of Performing Arts in Bratislava – VSMU, and Maria Zmarz-Koczanowicz discussed documentary education at National Film School in Lodz. What emerged from their fruitful discussion? Vít Janeček, Kamila Boháčková, Maria Zmarz-Koczanowicz, Attila Kékesi, Peter Kerekes
1.17Czech Documentary AlchemyAmerican freelance critic Daniel Walber examines alchemy within contemporary czech experimental movies which were screened at the 20th Jihlava IDFF in the Fascinations: section.Daniel Walber
3.16Czech Docs on Public Service TVWhat shows the analysis of the programme composition of Czech Television?Kateřina Šardická
1.16Digital RestorationWhat goes on in Hungarian laboratories when restoring 14 Czech archive films?Jitka Lanšperková
6.15Scandinavian Freedom Comes at a High PriceRepresentatives of Danish and Swedish public television Danmarks Radio and Axel Arnö and their their approach to international documentary productionJitka Lanšperková
5.15Digitisation and its Stewardship AspectNotes from the discussion on the process of digitisation organised as part of the 19th Jihlava IDFFKateřina Šardická
2.15KVIFF Enthralled with Documentary FiguresAbout the relationship between Karlovy Vary International Film Festival and documentary moviesJitka Lanšperková
1.15Czech Television in NumbersHow many documentaries are produced annually by the Czech Television (CT)? What categories are they divided into and what does it cost?Tomáš Stejskal
1.13SportSix films that premiered at One World 2013 through the eyes of their authors

starší články

02. 05. 2016

from current issue:

New releaseShooting About KunderaDocumentarian Miloslav Šmídmajer describes the process of making a documentary about Milan Kundera with the working title “Milan Kundera: From the Joke to Insignificance.” Miloslav ŠmídmajerThemeNest in the bedroomPeter Hames, well-known British film historian and author of the book The Czechoslovak New Wave sent his remembrance to Karel Vachek to our magazine.Peter HamesThemeNever stop laughingPaolo Benzi, the Italian film producer and founder of the independent film production company Okta Film, describes for dok.revue how he met famous Czech documentary filmmaker Karel Vachek, who passed away last year. Paolo Benzi is also the main tutor of the Emerging producers in Ji.hlava IDFF.Paolo BenziThemeBehold, if the river is turbulent he is not frightenedIn this English issue of dok.revue we have collected some remembrances to Karel Vachek, the respected Czech documentarist who died in December 2020 at the age of 80. One of the contributors is Olaf Möller, a well-known film theorist and critic collaborating with many renowned film magazines (Film Comment or Sight & Sound), film museums and festivals (e.g. Il Cinema Ritrovato or International Film Festival Rotterdam).Olaf MöllerThemeEvery human being should get to wear comfy shoesThe Czech documentarist Karel Vachek was a chairperson of the jury at Yamagata international documentary film festival (YIDFF) in 2009. The board member of YIDFF and the former director of this festival, Asako Fujioka, has a remembrance of him smoking his pipe and going to the mountains with Japanese poet and filmmaker Yoshimasu Gozo to recite poetry to the skies.Asako FujiokaThemeLike the dog on the beach...American film historian Alice Lovejoy writes her remembrance of Karel Vachek, the remarkable Czech documentarist to whom we dedicate this English issue of dok.revue.Alice LovejoySportPandemic as an opportunityJi.hlava's Emerging Producers discuss the opportunity that can emerge from crisisSteve RickinsonInterviewThe times of lifelong careers are overAn interview with documentarian Jindřich Andrš, whose film A New Shift won the Czech competition section Czech Joy at Ji.hlava IDFF2020.Vojtěch KočárníkInterviewGoing to the Polish Turf with Our Own TeamInterview with documentary filmmakers Filip Remunda and Vít Klusák about their latest joint film project Once Upon a Time in Poland that shows how religion and faith are misused in contemporary Poland for mass manipulation and political purposes. The film‘s Czech premiere was held as part of the Ji.hlava International Documentary Film Festival 2020.Kamila BoháčkováIntroductionDok.revue 1.21This issue is dedicated to the doyen of Czech documentary filmmaking Karel VachekKamila Boháčková