A Place to Take a Breath

The film journalist Janis Prášil compares two documentary portraits of this year – Forman vs. Forman and Jiří Suchý: Tackling Life with Ease on his blog.

Freedom was the key word for life and work of Miloš Forman

The biographical pictures Forman vs. Forman (2019) by Helena Třeštíková and Jakub Hejna and Jiří Suchý: Tackling Life with Ease (2019) by Olga Sommerová tell stories about quest for freedom. The first one is set in the normalization Czechoslovakia and the second one in exile. They show Miloš Forman and Jiří Suchý coping with schizophrenic reality of the totalitarian society, which forces artists to decide between freedom and home. 

Miloš Forman counts among filmmakers who did not plan to emigrate. He was abroad when the occupation came and he was deciding whether to come or not to come back to his homeland, which changed into a trap during his absence. It was freedom redeemed by broken family bonds. Forman did not see his sons for seven years and his first marriage did not survive the exile. Třeštíková and Hajný highlight the topic of freedom and uprootedness, which goes back to director´s early childhood marked by the death of his parents in the concentration camp and his dreadful memories of the gestapo. An emotional compiled collage is permeated by rich archive materials showing dramatic social changes. The authors Třeštíková and Hejna managed once again – as in the story of Lída Baarová depicted in the film Doomed Beauty from 2016 – to interlink intimacy of a time-collecting documentary with the dramatic character of the conflict between personal history of an individual and great history of the society.

Forman´s film Audition represents initiatory experience for Helena Třeštíková. Works of the Czechoslovak new wave brought unbelievable authenticity to the cinema screens. However, not even a trivial everydayness can be apolitical in an environment which propagates doctrine of social realism. An inner conflict between the character and the environment of Forman´s early works continues also in his epic American stories. The topic of freedom is given a considerable space in excerpts from the films One Flew Over the Cuckoo´s Nest (1975), Hair (1979), Ragtime (1981) or The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996). The example of Amadeus (1984) shows schizophrenia of the system which betrays its own principles. The very same regime allowed its once citizen to shoot an epic for Americans in Prague and kept another artist, Václav Havel, in prison at the same time. After leaving for the exile, Forman meets another type of absence of freedom. “Nowhere are we free. However, if I should choose between lying at the mercy of an idiot or a viewer, the choice is clear.” The author comes to a conclusion that repression exists everywhere, but commercial pressure is more bearable than the ideological one.

Jiří Suchý tried to find his creative freedom within the system and by cementing people through entertainment free of any ideological order

The story Tackling Life with Easy (2019) about Jiří Suchý is less political. Instead of highlighting historical context, Sommerová underlines mainly personal experience of the main character. However, not only tragedies like Suchý´s first wife Běla´s and Jiří Šlitr´s deaths are shown. Political evens resonate, too. Semafor theatre became a society-wide phenomenon and its founders created a space for non-regime entertainment where people came to “breathe some fresh air”. Archive scenes showing burning Soviet tanks and shooting in the streets during the occupation are emotively tinged with the song by Suchý and Šlitr Jo, to jsem ještě žil from 1969. When the occupation started, Suchý and his wife were abroad. Personal reasons make him return home. He “is not an emigrant type” and his decision grows into a gesture of national loyalty. When he unexpectedly appears on the stage in Semafor theatre, the audience, thinking he is in London, gives him the greatest applause in his life. “People were glad that there is also someone who comes back.”

Though neither Forman nor Suchý belonged among dissidents, their stories did not remain apolitical. Třeštíková with Hejna and Sommerová as well extended a portrait of an individual with collective historic experience and showed how it is possible to deal with a repressive system. Suchý did so by finding his creative freedom within the system and by cementing people through entertainment free of any ideological order. Forman built up his new home abroad. Part of the documentary is spoken by Forman´s son Petr, who represents continuity on the personal level and also on the level of a collective story of the director who points out the fact that our country is free only on the paper and that it will take a long time before people free themselves inside.

Translated by Petra Ocelková

more articles from a section:  Review

1+2.19On Sounds by ImageThe film journalist Antonín Tesař writes about the new film The Sound Is Innocent directed by Johana Ožvold.Antonín Tesař
1+2.19 Music as a Lag Between Death and InfinityJanis Prášil ruminates on Solo – this year´s winner of Ji.hlava Czech Joy section – which comes to cinemas. Did the picture succeed in depicting the inner world, so hard to portray, of a mentally ill musician? And what if it is the illness itself which enables people to take a look into the grievous core of being?Janis Prášil
F2.18The Silence of Others This film by Almudena Carracedo and Rober Bahar, produced by the Almodóvar brothers, screams out for justice for the unpunished crimes of the Franco régime
F4.17China, 87. The OthersWill Tizard from Variety on the Opus Bonum selection China 87. The Others by Violaine de VillersWill Tizard
F2.17Máme tlakovú níž / Richard Müller: Nepoznaný
F1.17Also Known as JihadiWill Tizard from Variety on the Opus Bonum selection Also Known as Jihadi byEric BaudelaireWill Tizard
F1.17The Lust for PowerWill Tizard from Variety on Opus Bonum selection The Lust for Power by Tereza Nvotová (world premiere).Will Tizard
F1.17On the Edge of Freedom Sydney Levine from SydneysBuzz on First Lights selection On the Edge of Freedom by Jens Lengerke and Anita Mathal Hopland (central European premiere). Sydney Levine
F3.17Acts and IntermissionsColin Beckett on Opus Bonum selection Acts and Intermissions by Child Abigail (internationale premiere).Colin Beckett
F3.17Enticing Sugary Boundless or Songs and Dances about DeathColin Beckett on Between the Seas selection Enticing Sugary Boundless or Songs and Dances about Death by Tetiana Khodakivska and Oleksandr Stekolenko (world premiere). Colin Beckett

starší články

17. 12. 2019

from current issue:

New releaseShooting About KunderaDocumentarian Miloslav Šmídmajer describes the process of making a documentary about Milan Kundera with the working title “Milan Kundera: From the Joke to Insignificance.” Miloslav ŠmídmajerThemeNest in the bedroomPeter Hames, well-known British film historian and author of the book The Czechoslovak New Wave sent his remembrance to Karel Vachek to our magazine.Peter HamesThemeNever stop laughingPaolo Benzi, the Italian film producer and founder of the independent film production company Okta Film, describes for dok.revue how he met famous Czech documentary filmmaker Karel Vachek, who passed away last year. Paolo Benzi is also the main tutor of the Emerging producers in Ji.hlava IDFF.Paolo BenziThemeBehold, if the river is turbulent he is not frightenedIn this English issue of dok.revue we have collected some remembrances to Karel Vachek, the respected Czech documentarist who died in December 2020 at the age of 80. One of the contributors is Olaf Möller, a well-known film theorist and critic collaborating with many renowned film magazines (Film Comment or Sight & Sound), film museums and festivals (e.g. Il Cinema Ritrovato or International Film Festival Rotterdam).Olaf MöllerThemeEvery human being should get to wear comfy shoesThe Czech documentarist Karel Vachek was a chairperson of the jury at Yamagata international documentary film festival (YIDFF) in 2009. The board member of YIDFF and the former director of this festival, Asako Fujioka, has a remembrance of him smoking his pipe and going to the mountains with Japanese poet and filmmaker Yoshimasu Gozo to recite poetry to the skies.Asako FujiokaThemeLike the dog on the beach...American film historian Alice Lovejoy writes her remembrance of Karel Vachek, the remarkable Czech documentarist to whom we dedicate this English issue of dok.revue.Alice LovejoyInterviewThe times of lifelong careers are overAn interview with documentarian Jindřich Andrš, whose film A New Shift won the Czech competition section Czech Joy at Ji.hlava IDFF2020.Vojtěch KočárníkInterviewGoing to the Polish Turf with Our Own TeamInterview with documentary filmmakers Filip Remunda and Vít Klusák about their latest joint film project Once Upon a Time in Poland that shows how religion and faith are misused in contemporary Poland for mass manipulation and political purposes. The film‘s Czech premiere was held as part of the Ji.hlava International Documentary Film Festival 2020.Kamila BoháčkováIntroductionDok.revue 1.21This issue is dedicated to the doyen of Czech documentary filmmaking Karel VachekKamila Boháčková